"✨ 12 years of stories, history, and heritage with kushtiatown.com"

Select your language

What the PR system is: the potential and challenges of proportional representation in Bangladesh's context
What the PR system is: the potential and challenges of proportional representation in Bangladesh's context

The foundation of democracy is the proper reflection of the people's opinions. But the question is: does the vote the people cast find proper reflection in parliament? The system followed at present in Bangladesh's electoral arrangements is the 'single-member plurality system' (First Past The Post - FPTP).

Under this system, in each constituency the candidate who wins the most votes is the winner. As a result, in many cases it is seen that a candidate is elected to parliament with less than half of the total votes cast, and the remaining votes find no real reflection at all.

To overcome this limitation, the PR (Proportional Representation) system has emerged in political theory and democratic practice as an alternative.

What is the PR system

The PR, or Proportional Representation system, is a voting arrangement in which seats in parliament or a representative body are distributed in proportion to the total votes each party receives. That is, if a party wins 40% of the total votes nationally, it will receive approximately 40% of the seats in parliament too.

Example:

Suppose a country has 300 seats in parliament in all.

The result of the election's vote count is as follows:

  • Party 'A' has won 45% of the votes
  • Party 'B' has won 35% of the votes
  • Party 'C' has won 15% of the votes
  • Independents and others 5% of the votes

Under the PR system the seats would be distributed like this:

  • Party 'A' → 45% of 300 = 135 seats
  • Party 'B' → 35% of 300 = 105 seats
  • Party 'C' → 15% of 300 = 45 seats
  • Others → 15 seats

In this way every vote of the people is reflected in parliament. No vote is 'wasted', and the smaller parties too have the chance to enter parliament.

Types of the PR system

Several different forms of the PR system are in use around the world. The main ones are:

  1. The List System
    • Here each political party submits a list of its candidates.
    • The voter votes for the party, not for an individual.
    • Candidates are elected from the list in proportion to the votes the party receives.
    • Examples: the Netherlands, South Africa, Israel.
  2. The Mixed Member Proportional (MMP) system
    • Here one part of parliament is elected under FPTP, and the rest in proportion under PR.
    • Germany and New Zealand follow this system.
  3. The Single Transferable Vote (STV)
    • The voter chooses candidates in order of preference.
    • The vote is transferable — that is, if the first preference falls away, the second-preference candidate receives the vote.
    • It is comparatively complicated, but reflects the voter's will more fully.
    • Examples: Ireland, Malta.

The PR system in the international context

At present, more than 80 countries of the world use some form of the PR system.

  • Most countries of Europe — such as Sweden, Finland, Germany, Norway, the Netherlands — believe in proportional representation.
  • After South Africa introduced the PR system, representation of its various ethnic and political groups increased there.
  • New Zealand switched from FPTP to the mixed PR system in 1996, as a result of which women's and minorities' representation in parliament grew.

Bangladesh's context

In Bangladesh at present, under the constitution (Article 65), parliament's 300 general seats are elected directly by the people's votes — that is, under the FPTP system.

Some limitations of this arrangement are:

  1. A party can win an overwhelming majority in parliament while receiving fewer votes overall.
  2. Representation of the smaller parties in parliament becomes nearly impossible.
  3. Regional splits in the vote destroy the national reflection.

Example:

In the 2008 national election, the Awami League won about 48.04% of the total votes, but received 263 seats (87.66%). On the other hand, the BNP won 33.20% of the votes but received only 30 seats (10%).

This huge gap makes clear the disproportion between votes and seats.

Source: Bangladesh Election Commission (EC, 2008).

The prospects of implementing the PR system

If the PR system were introduced in Bangladesh, some positive changes could follow:

  1. The proper reflection of votes: every vote of the people would have an effect in parliament, strengthening the foundations of democracy.
  2. Growing participation of small parties and independent candidates: once the smaller parties' representation were assured, the diversity of political opinion would grow.
  3. Greater political coexistence: the tendency to form coalition governments would increase, which could foster mutual tolerance.

Probable challenges

But in Bangladesh's political reality, introducing the PR system carries some complications too:

  1. Political instability: because coalition governments hold differences of policy, stability could decline.
  2. Administrative complications: constitutional and technical changes would be needed to introduce the new vote-counting and seat-distribution processes.
  3. A shortfall of regional representation: if votes are counted nationally under the PR system, local issues may lose their representation.

The views of policymakers and researchers

The political analyst Dr Nurul Amin (University of Dhaka) holds that,

"If a system of proportional representation were introduced in a multi-party democracy like Bangladesh's, diversity would come to parliament; but before implementing it, administrative preparation and political consensus are essential."

On the other hand, an analysis report from the Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) states,

"To make parliamentary democracy in Bangladesh more inclusive, a partial (mixed) system could be introduced experimentally."

Sources:

    • Bangladesh Election Commission Reports, 2008–2024
    • CPD Working Paper on Electoral Reform, 2022
    • IDEA Handbook of Electoral Systems, 2021

The PR system is no magical solution, but it is the reflection of an arrangement in which every vote carries equal worth. In Bangladesh's reality, applying this system is still distant; but to ensure democratic representation and inclusive politics, policymakers may well turn their thoughts to it in the future.

Democracy's true worth will come when every voice of the vote echoes in parliament — that is the core philosophy of the PR system.

Sources:

      1. Bangladesh Election Commission, Official Results Archive (2008–2024)
      2. CPD Working Paper on Electoral Reform (2022)
      3. IDEA: International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (2021)
      4. Dr Nurul Amin, "Electoral Reform in Bangladesh: Challenges and Choices," Dhaka University Journal, 2023
      5. New Zealand Electoral Commission (2020): Mixed Member Proportional System Overview
Add comment
Posting any form of obscene comment is prohibited; doing so will result in legal action.

Subscribe to get the latest updates

About information

Subscribe to our newsletter and stay updated